
Evan Winks spent a year losing weight, from nearly 230 pounds to 145. He did it while waiting for Claire Morgan, a girl from his neighborhood he has liked since middle school. Before she left to study abroad, Claire promised to make their relationship public when she came home.
At the airport, Evan waits with flowers, but Claire walks out and kisses Ryan Cole, a popular guy from the literature program. Claire tells Ryan that Evan clings to her and that she gave him a teammate's backup account as her new one. That account has been texting Evan every day for a year, and it has been calling him babe.
Lucy Dawson, the teammate behind the account, is also Claire's best friend. Evan is angry that Lucy hid who she was for a whole year, and he does not trust her, yet he goes to Claire's welcome-home dinner to find her. There, he writes his username in red marker on Lucy's forearm, and she says she will add him.
Evan Winks, once close to 230 pounds, has spent a year losing weight and waiting for Claire Morgan, a girl from his neighborhood he has liked since middle school. At the airport, where he waits with flowers, Claire comes through arrivals and kisses Ryan Cole, a popular guy from the literature program. Ryan asks about Evan, and Claire says he clings to her and does not know she is home. Evan then finds out that the account that has texted him every day for a year belongs to Lucy Dawson, one of Claire's tennis teammates.
Lucy sends Evan a second gold box of chocolates, and when he asks why she is so good to him, she says it is because she likes him. After that, Evan goes to Claire's welcome-home dinner to find the woman behind the account. Claire snatches Lucy's phone, so Evan writes his username in red marker on Lucy's forearm, and Lucy agrees to add him. That night Claire storms into Evan's room, takes his phone, and kisses him against the wall, and Evan reminds her of the airport a year earlier, when he begged for a kiss before she left. He tells her they are over.
Lucy gives Evan a black warm-up top with Dawson and the number 12 on it, then spends a day with him at breakfast and an arcade. Evan is still angry that she hid who she was for a year, but he agrees to watch her exhibition match, where Claire drives a shot into Lucy's shoulder and the two women fight until officials remove them both. A video of the fight spreads across a campus forum, and when Evan reaches his seminar room, his old photos from before he lost weight are on his desk with one word written across them in red paint. Ryan mocks him there, and Evan asks Lucy outside her car whether she would kiss him if he still weighed 230 pounds.
Yes. Lucy apologizes for the lies, Evan agrees to be her boyfriend, and by the final match she is kissing him in front of the crowd.
Because when Evan apologized for being annoying, she could not let him keep believing it was his fault.
No. When Claire asks for another chance, Evan tells her she disgusts him, and later he says goodbye to her when she comes to his car.
Claire drives a shot into Lucy's shoulder, and after Lucy shoves her, the two women trade punches until officials remove both of them from the match.
Claire comes to Evan, saying she likes him now and asking for another chance, and he tells her she disgusts him. Later Lucy tells him she kept answering at first with only a few messages, but when he apologized for being annoying, she could not let him keep believing it was his fault. She apologizes, and they agree to start over with no more lies. Evan says yes when she asks him to be her boyfriend, and he kisses her.
Evan posts a timeline of his relationship with Claire, including the messages from Lucy's account, with a line saying he did not cheat on anyone. At the seminar room Ryan says Claire told him Evan was obsessed with her, and when Evan says he expects no apology, Ryan walks out. Three days later Claire waits by Evan's car and says their parents have known each other for twenty years, but Evan tells her she misses only the person he became, and asks whether she would still be standing there at his old weight. Ryan overhears and says Claire was trying to get Evan back. He walks to his car, and Claire looks lost as Evan says goodbye to her.
Lucy returns to competition near the end of the semester, after her shoulder has healed, and Evan cheers for her from the front row. On match point she chases down a deep shot and sends a backhand past her opponent, then runs to the stands and throws her arms around him. She kisses his cheek in front of everyone, and the crowd cheers.
Evan Winks
The lead, a childhood friend of Claire who has lost about 85 pounds to win her back and then finds out the person texting him is someone else.
Claire Morgan
Evan's childhood friend and the girl he has loved for years, who kisses Ryan at the airport and keeps Evan at a distance.
Lucy Dawson
Claire's tennis teammate and best friend, who ran the backup account that texted Evan for a year and later becomes his girlfriend.
Ryan Cole
A popular student who is with Claire when she returns, and who mocks Evan's weight.